In this week's episode, Jim sits down with Dr. Ashish Jha—physician, health policy expert, and former White House COVID-19 Response Coordinator—for a candid look at what the…
In this week's episode, Jim sits down with Dr. Ashish Jha—physician, health policy expert, and former White House COVID-19 Response Coordinator—for a candid look at what the pandemic revealed about how America actually works under pressure.
This conversation moves well beyond COVID.
Dr. Jha explains what happens inside government during a crisis, why emergency powers quietly reshape policy across the entire system, and how short-term urgency consistently crowds out long-term planning.
From there, the discussion turns to the deeper structural issue: healthcare.
The U.S. is on track to spend roughly $70 trillion on healthcare over the next decade —a number that sits at the center of federal debt, state budgets, and household finances. But the real problem isn’t how much care we use—it’s what we pay for it.
Jim and Dr. Jha break down:
Why prices—not utilization—are driving costs How innovation is both life-saving and financially destabilizing Why hospitals lack real surge capacity And why meaningful reform continues to stall They also tackle harder questions around personal responsibility, prevention, and whether a system can be both compassionate and financially sustainable.
At the core of the conversation is a broader insight:
Welcome to The Puck, Venture Capital and Beyond, a show that examines the changing landscape of our world. Before we dive in, a quick word about who I am and why we're here. I'm Jim Bier, corporate lawyer and restructuring professional. I've spent the last two decades helping companies navigate their toughest transitions. And about eight years ago, I found myself having fascinating conversations with clients and friends about everything from venture capital to the broader shifts happening in our economy and society.
Those discussions were simply too good, so the puck was born. Now while we started on venture capital, hence the podcast name, the Puck Venture Capital and Beyond, We've naturally evolved to focus more on the and beyond portion of the title. Today, we explore how business intersects with the bigger forces shaping our world. I still run my restructuring practice by day, but now I get to host these conversations by night. It has become one of the most rewarding parts of my life.
Today's guest continues that tradition. Then there is a broad middle of 70% of Americans, some a little to the left, some a little to the right, but all generally pretty reasonable. That's the group that is not being listened to. They are the ones that we should be focused on to make policy suggestions for that broad middle. Today in the Puck, we're speaking with Doctor.
Ashish Jha, physician, health policy scholar, former Dean of Brown School of Public Health, and the White House COVID nineteen response coordinator. This is a conversation about systems under stress, how American health care actually works when you look under the hood, what the pandemic revealed about our institutional strength and fragilities, and why public health should be understood not just as medicine, but as economic infrastructure and national security. We'll explore crisis governance, hospital strain, federal debt, preparedness architecture, and the harder question beneath it all, whether institutional trust can be rebuilt in a polarized democracy. There's a lot to cover, so let's get to it. So, doctor Ashish Jha, welcome to the Puck.
Hey. Thanks so much for having me here. So just for our audience, just to get a little bit of an intro into who you are for those that haven't heard of you, can you just take a moment and tell us a little bit about your background? Sure. I am happy to.
So I'm a physician. I actually, I was born in India. I grew up in Canada for many years. And then became a doctor, spent most of my life as an academic, studying The US healthcare system, cost, quality, access, how do we make those things better? And then about ten years ago, in 2016, 2017, became really interested in the topic of pandemics and pandemic risk based on some work I had done, and got very worried that we were heading towards a global pandemic and we were not ready.
And it started sounding like one of those crazy people who kept saying that a pandemic is coming, a pandemic is coming. And everybody's like, what's wrong with this guy? And then the pandemic hit. And then once the pandemic hit, I am spending a lot of my time formally, informally advising governments and policymakers and speaking to the public about COVID, and then went and spent about a year and a half running the COVID response for President Biden. Really came in in the second year of the presidency with the goal of my goal when I joined the administration was we needed to bring the emergency to an end.
We needed to get rid of all the mandates and all the things that had gotten into our strategy. And I needed to get us prepared for future outbreaks and pandemic. So I was really I thought of myself as a guy to end the pandemic. Part of ending a pandemic is you gotta manage it well enough that you can convince people that it's time to end it. So, anyway, that's my background, and I'm excited to be Well, no.
We're excited to have you. And I guess when you talk about, you know, your concerns before COVID, I mean, again, what was it you were most worried about in our health care system that you didn't think people were paying enough attention to? Great question. So there were two sets of issues that I was worried about. I mean, first, I was very worried that the risk of a of a global pandemic had gone up dramatically in the last, in the ten or fifteen years preceding that time, so last fifteen, twenty years now, and that our public health infrastructure was not sort of ready for it.
And then the second was that I was worried that our healthcare delivery system, our hospitals, our doctors, A, weren't really aware of the risks. And B, if public health failed, they would be on the front lines. And then they didn't have the capacity, they didn't have the, you know, the what was necessary to be able to manage it on the on the front lines. And so a lot of what I did in 2018 and 2019 in talking about this was saying, how do we begin to build that resilience that we're gonna need if a pandemic hits? Right.
And then when it did hit and you arrived in 2022 and you looked under the hood, I mean, what was it that you found that most surprised you? You mean when I arrived in the government in 2022? Yeah. Exactly. Yeah.
From from academia to kind of looking under the hood in in the government. Yeah. Our US government is an incredible, like, behemoth of an entity. Like, people often think about it as the government's policy is this. One of the things I came to realize very early on was well, two things that I thought were sort of interesting.
One was even in early 'twenty two, the pandemic was having effects in pretty much every part of our society, whether you were in the commerce department thinking about America's kind of commerce strategy around the globe, to whether you were in labor or obviously inside health, to our Department of Defense, that it was affecting every part of our society and every part of our government. The second, which I thought was really interesting, was that the Trump administration, in the last year of the Trump administration, this is obviously the first Trump administration, had used the powers of an international emergency to do tons and tons of policy things. When you have a national emergency, it actually gives you a lot of running room and you can do lots of things that may not even be associated with the emergency. And they had done that. By the way, this is not an anti Trump criticism because the Biden administration has done the same thing in their first year of the Biden administration.
Sure. And so when I came in, one of the things I realized was, Oh my God, if we end the emergency, all, like, hundreds and hundreds of policies are going to fall apart immediately, and it's going to be super disruptive. So we're going to have to do a very orderly transition act. Last point I'll make is I, and this is probably the part that I think maybe you were getting at, is one of the things I came to realize, is that government is actually not as good as it needs to be for planning for the future. That especially in an emergency, everything is about what's the crisis today, what's on the media today, what do we need to manage today.
And you have to create space, political, mental, financial space to make investments for the next three, five, ten years because there's no political urgency to do that. There's never urgency for planning and for preparedness. The urgency always is, solve the problem of today. And so lifting up the hood, I realized, Oh, no one is planning for the future. I gotta start planning for the future.
So in that regard, if an emergency hit us next year, for instance, would it feel different to you? I mean or what would you be worried most about? Yeah. Well, I'll start by saying this. The risk of a biologically driven emergency is gotten dramatically higher even in the last five years.
And I want to just take a minute to explain why I say that. One is obviously the pandemic risks that I was worried about in 2018, 2019, that continues. In fact, if you think about what I was worried about, things like globalization and urbanization, none of that has changed. In fact, it continues to get more substantial. There are two new risk actors that are now in play that I wasn't thinking about in 2018.
One is biological engineering. The phenomenal scientific gains in CRISPR and synthetic biology and AI has meant that the ability to engineer pathogens is totally different than it was before. And we have lots of evidence, both from our intelligence, but also from public information, that lots of people are working on engineered pathogens. And then last is there's been this massive proliferation of labs around the world that are tinkering with viruses, that are tinkering with bacteria, and the chances of a leak out of one of those labs has gone way up. So the risk profile is I thought it was bad in 2018, it is just substantially worse now.
Now that all sounds, again, very doomsday. So I'm not a doomsday guy, I'm always an optimist. I'm like, What are we gonna do about this? If an emergency hit us next year, there are some upsides and downsides compared to where we were in 2018. We know a lot more about how to respond, I think, than we did then.
We have built some set of capabilities that we didn't have in 'eighteen and 'nineteen. And I think the chances that we'll be able to respond effectively are in some ways, they're better. But in some ways, they're worse because one of the unfortunate things that happened out of COVID was this, like, sort of deep polarization where half the country thinks that COVID responds Actually, I wouldn't even say this. Let me say this. A chunk of the country thinks that we way overreacted.
A chunk of the country thinks we way underreacted. And a large middle is confused. And I worry that political actors will use that division in a way that's not gonna be constructive. The last point I'll make on the political division front is, yes, I work for one of the I worked for the Biden administration, but I have always been a very bipartisan guy. And I actually think a vast majority of Americans are very reasonable on these issues.
And there is a way for us to manage future crises if we don't super politicize it right away. You know, we're not great at that. We politicize almost everything. That's the part we gotta fight the temptation. And I think if we do, yeah, I think if a new crisis arrives next year, we can do okay.
Well, no, that's comforting. And when you look at I mean, we're gonna get into some of the financial aspects, but when you look at the conditions of our hospital system right now, how do you feel that that's holding up? Yeah. So let's talk about the healthcare system itself. So obviously, hospitals vary, I think, widely in their finances.
I mean, look, first of all, every hospital CEO that I know cries poverty and says that they're losing money every year. The truth is, some hospital systems, especially large, I think many large hospital systems are doing fine. Now going through the pandemic, a lot of them took a big hit. Inflation was a real problem for a lot of health systems. But I think some large chunk of hospitals are kind of financially unreasonable ground.
But part of what they have done is try to be efficient and lean, and they don't have a lot of reserve for building up capacity. So if we get a new hit, their ability to scale up and have taken care of 50% or 100 more patients in short term is going to be very, very little. And there really are a large chunk of hospitals that are financially struggling. They take care of a lot of Medicaid patients. They might take care of a lot of uninsured patients.
And for them, there's a real set of financial struggles. And I think obviously a crisis would put them over. So I think of the industry as being a mixed bag of some that are gonna do okay, but our health care system doesn't have a lot of resilience built in. So when you look at the fact that, as you say, there's not a lot of resilience built in, and you look at also what's driving our federal debt, and and, you know, a lot of it is the Social Security and the Medicare expenditures. Yeah.
How do we, you know, in a democracy where seven out of the 10 Americans want their taxes to go down and seven out of 10 Americans want their benefits to go up Yeah. How do we do a better job getting our health care under control where where it's actuarially sound as opposed to just Yes. Putting it under the carpet? Yeah. Oh my god.
This is can you ask me a harder question? No. I'm kidding. That is the I was gonna say that's the million dollar question. It's actually prob the way I look at it, that is the $70,000,000,000,000 question.
And the reason I use that number is that is probably a reasonable bet of how much money we're gonna spend on health care over the next decade. And that is, by the way, just an enormous amount of money, and it may in fact be an under an underestimation. This is a place where I think there is not enough serious thinking about what's happening. The political fights in Washington are about ACA subsidies, yes or no. And I remind people, ACA subsidies are largely a fight about who pays the bill, not why is the bill so big.
And we have a whatever our debt is up to, 30 some odd trillion dollars. And as you said, the healthcare is one of the major drivers of ongoing federal deficits. It's a huge drain on the Pentagon budget, it's a huge drain on state budgets, and then it's a huge drain on families' budgets. And I don't believe there is a serious enough set of conversations about what we need to do about it, and I think that that is a problem. So I actually am writing a series right now for the Boston Globe, a nine part series.
And funny, when I pitched it to the Globe, they're like, Well, could you just write this as a single op ed? I'm like, No. Because the problem is it's complicated. And in 800 words, I cannot tell you enough detail all the things we need to be doing to make our healthcare system more financially sustainable. My personal view is that we have completely screwed up the market dynamics in healthcare.
A lot of it is because of bad government regulation. A lot of it is because of consolidation. And if you are somebody who believes that markets are an important element of disciplining prices and creating efficiency, well, we're not we're not practicing that well enough inside of here. So we're I think I'm now piece number four or three or four is gonna be coming out next week or soon. But the point here is that the goal is to lay out a series of policy ideas that feds or states can implement.
And one last point, when I was talking to the editors of The Globe, I said, Look, the one thing I will promise you is every single piece will upset somebody. Because if your goal is to save a lot of money but not upset anybody, you're not living in a reality based world. When you save money, that's somebody's revenue that you are hurting. So the truth is that I actually think we can save money on healthcare, we can do it in a way that preserves access, improves quality, actually improves access. But you can't do it without upsetting some vested interest that wants to see those dollars flowing into their pockets.
And we'll see if political leaders take up this fight or they decide that the politics of this is too hard and they're going to keep sweeping it under the rug. That I can't I don't know. I'm like, I'm no one calls me for political advice. I don't know how to give bad advice. I do know that there are real policy things we can do to make health care better.
Well, and and we've, at the Puck, decided we wanted to spend a little more time on this because it does seem to be a central issue. People are worried about the economy and our debt. And when you look at, again, putting political issues aside, when you close our borders and you have an aging population, you have fewer and fewer people working and contributing at the bottom of the pyramid Yeah. And you have an aging population with more and more sophisticated medicine and and operations who were not even available twenty five, thirty, fifty, a hundred years ago. I mean, the world has really changed.
Yes. And so, you know, we we're in a situation where politicians obviously don't like talking about things that, as you said, require shared sacrifice, but we're gonna, at some point, have a crisis. We're gonna have, at some point, a need to make some kind of a change. Yes. And the question is, is there enough institutional fortitude and creativity within the profession to figure out, okay, this is a way to, in essentially, make an actuarial sound system.
And And when you look at states and you look at other countries, I mean, are there things that give you hope that we could actually do to make this actuarially sound? Absolutely. And and let me actually double click on a couple of points you made because I think they're very important. One is there is a chunk of and I know it's not a political conversation, but there's a chunk of the political elite who think deficits, debt doesn't matter. I maybe I don't know.
And again, I'm not an economist. Maybe ten years, fifteen years ago, it didn't. We're now at a point where I actually think that that is not a sustainable political art. And I have lots of evidence behind why I think that is not going to work. And my friends on the left who are like, We just should cover everybody for everything.
I'm like, I'd love that. But if that's going to drive deficits substantially higher, the politics of that is going to become untenable. So I want to cover everybody. Those are my values. That's not a but I want to figure out how to do it in a much more financially sustainable right?
Okay. So then your question is, are there models that we can look into for sustainability? And the answer in my mind is first, let's talk about the international stuff. The answer there in my mind is yes and no. And so you go like, Okay, give me an answer, don't give me a yes and no.
People are always looking for the simple solution, right? Like the silver bullet. And so I see this all the time where my friends on the left are like, We should just do what Denmark does. Like, Okay, Denmark is lovely. 5,000,000 people, smaller than Massachusetts.
And then there are other people who are my friends on the right who are like, our house system should do what Singapore does. I'm like, Singapore is awesome. It's a city state with seven and a half or 8,000,000 people. Like, America will not become Singapore, America will not become Denmark. That's like not a realistic We can learn from those places, but that's not a realistic approach.
We need to do We need to come up with uniquely American solutions. Okay. So then, so go to the second part of your question around states. I have always believed, I know it's a cliche, that states are the laboratories of democracy. They're also the laboratories of policy.
If you look at the Affordable Care Act, however you feel about the Affordable Care Act, Act. Obamacare, Affordable Care Act, was modeled after Romneycare, which was in Massachusetts. Like, that's how we have made national policy is we've had states try a bunch of things and when they're happy about it, or even if they're not, like then we try to kind of nationalize them. So I think like policies around figuring out how to get a lot more competition happen. If you're, you know, you're a more blue state and you want to try price regulation a bit more aggressively than that, I think that's fine.
Experiment with that. See what that looks like. There's a bunch of things states can do to experiment. I don't have a magic bullet. I can't tell you that one policy will work for Texas, Massachusetts, and Mississippi, and Montana.
But I can say that if states are willing to do a lot more of this kind of stuff, we can learn, and we can make our system more efficient. So you you mentioned Obamacare and then what was done in Massachusetts. Is Obamacare, which I my understanding is prices have gone up a lot. When you look at what was going on under Massachusetts, were they identical in their approach or did did things get done differently in Massachusetts that politically weren't we weren't able to do with Obamacare? Look, what I'm about to say, Will, we get people mad at me on both sides of the aisle, but I feel like that's my specialty, just having people be mad at me.
Right. So let's talk a little bit about Obamacare and what I think it has accomplished and what it has not accomplished. Okay. It has absolutely expanded access for about 20 to 25,000,000 people. There are about 25,000,000 Americans who have healthcare today who would not have had it without Obamacare.
And that's real, and that's for those people very important. On healthcare spending, remember it was called the Affordable Care Act, and I still have lots of friends who were part of the ACA, creating the ACA, the Obamacare, who tell me absolutely ASEA should lower health care spending. No, it didn't. It just did. I'm sorry.
Like I've looked at all the data, I wish I could believe that the Affordable Care Act lowered health care spending. I don't see it. I also am not convinced that it caused some massive explosion in spending. Look, spending numbers were looking really bad before the ACA. I remember, you know, the CEO of Ford, before the Affordable Care Act was passed, talking about how he spent more on healthcare than he spent on steel.
And so we already had a healthcare cost crisis and that has only gotten worse. And I can't tell you if we had never passed the ACA whether things would be worse today or better today. My best guess is probably wouldn't be that different on the spending stuff. Alright. Massachusetts largely did the same thing.
They expanded access. They put in a bunch of policies under Romneycare to try to control spending. I don't think they did very much because no one has really addressed the underlying reasons of why health care spending is so bad, so high. And the policies that the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare put in to try to curtail spending, they were pretty weak sauce. I mean, they were well intentioned.
Again, those are my friends. I think what they did was right at the time. I don't think it has, like, I don't think it has paid off in a substantial way. So when you look at what's driving costs Yes. And when you look at discussions whether or not it's having a single payer plan or requiring everyone to have health insurance or giving the money directly to people so that they can buy and create more competition, What are the think tanks?
What is the the the general consensus about what could be done to try to lower costs? Great question. So let's talk about where I think there is agreement, and then let's talk about where there is disagreement. And I think that I'm going to talk about, of course, like good faith disagreement. There's always people who are out there crazy, but let's so there if you ask why, why are we over $5,000,000,000,000 heading towards $7,000,000,000,000 a year?
What's driving that? One is prices. We don't actually use that much more healthcare than Europeans, our prices are just much higher. And we can talk about what would drive prices down to the extent that that was a that we want to do that. Obviously, an aging population, and then something you said that was exactly right, is in the last, not just twenty years, but in the last five years, seven years, we have had an explosion of new treatments coming online that are awesome.
GLP-1s are amazing at like, not just reducing obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure, cardiovascular disease, but they're expensive. We have genetic treatments now for sickle cell disease and hemophilia. That's awesome. Lifesaving. Dollars 3 to 4,000,000 per treatment.
So, so there is a set of issues that are driving healthcare costs that are really truly out of control. Okay. And as a physician, I don't wanna slow down the innovation. Like, I don't want to say, I don't want more genetic treatments for people with horrible diseases. I want more of those treatments, not fewer of those treatments, right?
Okay. So what do we do? I think there is general consensus that we got to do something around the price problem. That because of market consolidation in many healthcare markets, prices are just completely ridiculous. People on the right, generally say let's focus on competition, both on the supply side and on the demand side.
On the demand side, you get more competition by giving people more money into their health savings accounts and letting them be consumers. People on the left are like, Let's do price caps and price regulation. My personal view is let's experiment with both. Look, Vermont will probably take a different approach than South Dakota. That's okay.
Let's try it. See what works. And it might be that the strategy in Vermont works for Vermont but won't work in South Dakota, but I'm game for a bunch of experiments on that. I think that there are cautionary tables on all fronts. Consumerism is something that I have talked a lot about, I believe in kind of almost on a faith based belief.
But the truth is that the data so far hasn't really given us a lot of reasons to believe that consumers are going to be that people are going to be great consumers. At the time they're making decisions, they're often either it's an emergency or they're swayed by whatever their doctor tells them. So consumerism as a policy is one I like in concept, but it has not yet borne out, and we really need to think about how do we make it more effective if we're going to use that as one strategy. Price regulation, a few states have tried it kind of in a weak way and it's also not been great. But I want to try it much more aggressively in some places.
And so I don't again, I think there's broad consensus among the think tanks of what's driving our healthcare spending problems. And then of course, on the right, they come up with different solutions. And on the left, and my view is, let's try a few of these out in different places in America, and then let's see what works and what doesn't. Now from your perspective, it would appear that there's not enough experimentation and dramatic movement towards these approaches. Is that just because of all the political polarization and the demonization that's exacerbated because of AI and algorithms and making everybody afraid?
Look. I do think there is a little bit of a problem of political courage among our political leaders at the state and federal level. And the experiments that have happened have been very, very weak. And I wanna see I absolutely think The reason why I wanna see more experimentation is because I am not convinced that I have all the answers for healthcare complexity in America. And I have met a lot of smart people, many of whom are convinced that they have all the right answers.
I'm not convinced they have the right answers. We all have parts of the answer. So I think the best answer is, let's try a few different things in a few different places. Let's try them in real. Like, don't give me a little minor, like, oh, for two percent of our patients, we'll give them a little more money in their health savings account.
Like, that's not gonna shift the market. That's too small. If you really wanna go into consumerism and health savings accounts, like let's do that in a very substantial way. And see if you can get the market to start functioning and price signals to start working and competition to start driving down prices. Like, let's actually experiment with that.
Don't give me like, for a small number of people, we're going to do this one tiny thing. And same thing, on the other side. And political leaders, I want to see them have the courage to do this because anything they do, you are absolutely right. The opposite, the other side, is gonna demonize them. Right?
And it's gonna if you if you do something on the health savings account, people are gonna be like, you're screwing over sick people and they're gonna all die and you're a terrible leader. Or if you get into price regulations, you're like, You're a communist and you're trying to I'm like, That's Switzerland has a very market driven system. They do price regulation. No one looks at Switzerland and says, That's a communist country. Switzerland's awesome.
Like, it's a very dynamic, lovely, very expensive place. So, like, I think if we can turn down the political rhetoric and have a little more courage from political leaders to try these things, yeah, we'll learn a lot about what's gonna work here. So from your perspective, is it something where, again, you and your colleagues can, again, encourage certain states that are more open to it than others? I mean, one of the things people are talking about is that California's got some real financial challenges right now. But depending on who wins in 2028, the federal government may step in and try to bail it out again.
I mean, are there states that are really struggling with this right now that are starting to make real changes? Well, I would actually go even broader and say, look. I think consumers, Americans, citizens are struggling with healthcare spending. And if affordability is the big issue of 2026, healthcare affordability is probably at the top of that list. Actually, there's a new pullout from the Kaiser Family Foundation that asks Americans, of all the affordability concerns, what are their tops?
And healthcare comes out as number one. So I don't even think you need a state in a financial crisis. I think there's plenty of political wins to harness if you want to take on the affordability issue. And so, you know, I do myself in public, I write about things, I speak publicly. But I also talk to a lot of political leaders quietly.
And I will tell you in general what I say to them, which is, if you're ever going to have courage to, like, come out with some concrete things, or if you're actually a political leader right now in government, if there's ever an opportunity to say, I'm going to really try to tackle this, now is actually a good political time to do it. You know, if a state is just in huge financial problem and getting billing it out, that is not a long term solution. Whether that's a, you know, a red state or a blue state, I wanna see real structural solutions. And my hope is you're gonna see some number of political leaders step up and say, yes, I'm gonna do that. But the challenge, like, for instance, as I'm listening to you, I mean, we know again, keeping politics out of this.
We know the Trump administration is talking about affordability. Yep. And we know that the midterms are coming up and both sides are trying to figure out what to do. But the interesting thing is when you attack affordability, as you said, there's gonna be winners and losers. And the the the real challenge, it seems to me, is that can you build a consensus where it's enough benefit for 60 or 70% of the people that it can drown out those people that are angry on on the fringes?
That is an impact that question. Look, losers always scream more loudly than winners. That's just the reality. Right? That's the reality.
Right. And especially if like, if you do a policy that's like 80% of Americans are better off, but a powerful political interest is worse off, The powerful political interest will scream like crazy and the 80% of people will benefit, but they may not even totally appreciate that they're benefiting, right? So this is the problem of politics. In my view, you actually gave the solution, which is you got to build a coalition. And that coalition has got to be businesses.
Because yes, it's consumers paying a lot. It's companies paying a lot for healthcare. Like fifteen years ago, the CEO of Ford was saying he was paying more for healthcare than steel. That is a problem that businesses around the country So you got to get the business community on board to say, Yes, we understand that you're going to have some political costs of this, but we are grateful that you're taking this on. I think this is a place where you can bring labor unions in because labor unions pay a ton out of their, like, funds for healthcare.
And if we can make that more affordable, that makes their lives easier. Obviously, I have lots of patient advocacy groups who care deeply about affordability. So what I again, I'm not a political analyst and I don't give political advice, but when I talk to political leaders and give them policy advice, they're like, Well, how do I manage a politics on this? I said, Well, that's your job, not mine. But I'll give you this, which is you've got to build the coalition of people who are going to benefit.
And that coalition has got to scream as loudly as the people who lose. Otherwise, we're just constantly going to be stuck in the status quo, and that's not working for anybody. Yeah. And it seems to me I mean, again, the the the two issues, putting aside how you create more competition, whether or not you have more doctors or you solve certain things with AI, I mean, the the fact is that if we wanna have the best drugs in the world and we wanna have patents and we wanna have have all these new amazing treatments, whether or not it's for rheumatoid arthritis or different cancer treatments. I mean, these drugs, as you said, are incredibly expensive.
Yeah. So that's an issue with an aging population. Yeah. And then you also have a situation where we have a very unhealthy portion of our society, whether or not it's from smoking Absolutely. Or not eating healthy.
And then there's this whole issue about, well, but people are doing the best they can, and are we fat shaming, or are we otherwise criticizing people? And and so, again, I love your idea about businesses somehow encouraging people to do more preventative things or otherwise to be healthy, but you're not seeing a lot of discussion about this. Yeah. Look. I have plenty of disagreements with our current health secretary, but I think one of the things that he has done is brought some of these issues more to the forefront, and I think that's good.
Let me say this about all of this. Like, our our conversations and our dialogue on this stuff sometimes drives me crazy. We have a lot of obesity in America. We have to call that out. It's a real problem.
I'm not being, like, mean to people who are obese. I don't blame them or say they think they're terrible people or they're morally weak. Like, that's not useful. It's actually not a right way to think about it. I think the reality is that we have a country where again, I generally think it's we spend too much time looking for bills.
I don't believe that that's constructive. Food companies are not villains. They have an incentive. What are the incentives of the food companies? To sell more food.
Like, that's literally their job. You're the CEO of a food company, your job is to sell more food. How do you do that? You make it tastier. You make it more addictive without, you know, doing anything illegal.
You try to make your products more attractive. Well, they've been very successful. Doritos are very tasty. I don't eat a lot of Doritos, but every time I have a Dorito, I'm like, Oh, yeah. I should have more Doritos.
I don't actually do it. But the point is, they're tasty, right? I mean, maybe not everybody loves Doritos. But my but the point is that we have got to think about how do we get towards more healthy eating? How do we make healthier food cheaper, more accessible?
And obviously, smoking continues to be a big problem. Getting more people to exercise more, all of those are real things that we need to be doing. I'd like to do it without vilifying and saying, you know, we don't need to say mean things to fat people, but we actually kind of went overboard the other way. I would say five years ago, we were like, Oh, don't fat shame. Don't say being fat is bad.
As a doctor, I'm like, Being obese is bad. Like, being obese is just bad for your health. So we should absolutely encourage. And I actually think GLP-1s are awesome because GLP-1s help people lose weight. So yes, we need a multi part comprehensive strategy on this, and eating better, exercising is definitely gonna be an important part of all.
When you look at life insurance and when you look at car insurance, if you have it, you know, if if they test you health wise for life insurance and you have certain markers or otherwise, they charge you more. Yep. And if you drink and drive or you have a lot of speeding tickets, your rates go up dramatically. Yep. I don't think we have the same thing in health care.
And from a perspective of making something actuarially sound, how do we ever get this under control if we don't have some types of standards that influence the pricing of health care? It's a great question. Okay. So here are the positives and negatives of, like, the issue that you're raising. In many ways, the Affordable Care Act actually banned the ability to do actuarial testing, right?
So let's talk about two ways of thinking about that problem because I think they're both important. One way to think about that is if you smoke, actually smoking you can get higher, you have higher health insurance premiums. But if you're overweight, if you have diabetes, if you have high blood pressure, if you just think about this from an actuarial point of view, you should be more expensive to insure. And in that world, it makes sense that insurance companies would charge you more. Okay.
And that would create an incentive for you to lose weight or exercise more or get your high blood pressure under control. There's this flip side of that that I think is also super complicated and very important, which is if you're a woman who at the age of 40 gets breast cancer, you then may become uninsurable. From a societal point of view, we have decided that's unacceptable. And I on a personal moral level, I think that's unacceptable. I agree.
So what do you do about that? Yep. But the truth is a 40 year old woman who's had breast cancer is actually much more expensive than a 40 year old woman who's not had breast cancer. Right. And that's the whole pre existing condition problem.
And it's very hard to solve this for one group, I. E. Charge people more for obesity and high blood pressure, without also causing a problem for the other group, which is charge more for somebody who's had breast cancer or charge somebody who's born with a genetic disorder. And that combination is, I think, what has caused this problem. And ultimately, the reason of the Affordable Care Act's provision of banning preexisting conditions was so popular.
I mean, that pulls at like ninety percent. It's because people don't want that 40 year old woman who's had breast cancer to be priced out of the insurance market for the rest of her life. I don't want. So, again, look, there are probably, like, people who are more sophisticated on insurance schemes who might have a solution here. My general view on this has come to be, we should figure out how to cover everybody.
We should use other policy strategies to encourage people to lose weight, to exercise, do other things, including making GLPs more available, figuring out how to make healthy food more available, creating incentives for better exercise, all that stuff. But using insurance premiums is just hard because I don't know how to do it for one group without without screwing over the other group, if that makes sense. I think, you know, one thing we've talked about is that if you're going to, again, try to make this fair and cover people with preexisting conditions, one way to do that is you increase the pool of people paying into insurance, and so you get young people that are required to have insurance, which politically we haven't been able to do. And then the other thing is we're somehow equating something like being born with the BRCA mutation or other preexisting conditions with volition. I mean, you don't hear a lot of sympathy for people that drink and drive.
I mean, you could say, well, they're depressed at work. They're they're drinking because they really have a lot of stress in their lives. No. That doesn't carry a lot of weight. When it comes to other things like how much we exercise, whether or not we smoke, whether or not we eat healthy or not, there seems to be this notion that we are equating that with, again, preexisting conditions that are not volitional.
And if we don't have real critical thinking, if we don't have real adult conversations around these issues, and we just keep, you know, having sympathy for everybody, I think there's that quote, if you're kind to those, you should be cruel. You end up being cruel to those. You should be kind. If we're not gonna start to make tougher decisions, we're gonna end up destroying it for everybody. Yeah.
I hear you, and I'm very sympathetic to that. And the way I think about this is on the there's a spectrum. It's not that some things are volitional and some things are out of control, right? And then there's a second issue, which is the effects on others. So one of the reasons we are completely unsympathetic to drinking and driving, and we should be unsympathetic to drinking and driving, Is that it's not that you're just harming yourself, you might kill somebody else.
Sure. And that, I think, is the game changer that basically says, No, we are not going to be tolerant of drinking and driving. And I completely agree with that. On the spectrum of volitional to non volitional, I think we'd all agree that a kid born with some genetic disorder that's gonna lead to his or her life being very financially, health wise expensive, as a society we should figure out how to take care of that kid. Sure.
Right? Okay. And that's completely nonfolicious. Versus somebody who really could be exercising more, eating better, and they're not. Smoking is a little bit, but not totally in the full book because it's clearly nicotine is very, very addictive.
Right? And so there's a little bit of that as a problem. And again, I think there's obviously a volitional component to it, but there is a spectrum across this range of things. What I would like to do is figure first of all, I agree with you, we should have adult conversations about this. We don't need to lump everybody into the same bucket.
And we should really think about what policies are going to drive better behavior for things that are truly volitional. And then what policies are going to work on reducing things that are quasi volitional. Like, actually we know that tobacco taxes dramatically cut back on how many kids start smoking. Because when you're 15, you're insanely price sensitive. And if a pack of cigarettes costs $15 or $10, the chances you're gonna pick up smoking is just very low.
And that's good because if you don't get addicted at 15, you probably won't get addicted at 30, you probably will never be a smoker, right? So I'm actually in pretty favor of those kinds of policies that shift things just to make it harder to do things that are bad for you. That makes sense. So when you look at where we are today Yeah. Is there momentum in certain directions that give you real hope in terms of progress?
Well, I'm loving where the scientific community is. I mean, I think the science behind the new generation of treatments, as you said, for RA, lupus, cancer, cardiovascular disease, it's kinda mind blowing. And, you know, I even think about things like diabetes or high blood pressure. People have a hard time taking a pill every day. Right.
There are treatments coming out for high blood pressure where you're gonna get an infusion once every six months and it'll manage your blood pressure. That's pretty amazing. It'll be very expensive. But so I am very excited about where the science is and all the good stuff that's coming. I do see in the next generation of political leaders, often a lot of younger ones, who are unfortunately not at the top of the political leadership, either in the Democratic or Republican party, who are talking about affordability in a much more realistic way.
I I think that gives me hope for the future that maybe our next generation of political leaders. I think about, for instance, my Congressman, one of the smartest people I think in Congress, Jake Auchincloss. He's from a very blue district, but the truth is, he's very bipartisan in his thinking. And he's talking about like real policy solutions for how do we do this? And very bipartisan.
That gives me hope that we're going to have a new generation of political leaders who are going to do this stuff. I want to see more courage from governors, mayors, or some of our leaders, top leaders in Washington. It's good to have these conversations about how we make America healthy again. But with all due respect to our current health secretary, getting rid of food dyes from food is not in the top 20 list of like what's gonna make a difference. We do have to figure out how to deal with processed foods.
I do think we do need to deal with drug affordability. We need to make our healthcare markets work better, and we need more experimentation, as we've been discussing. Makes sense. There's obviously the set of challenges that exist in our healthcare system. I brought up $70,000,000,000,000 as how much money we're going to spend, the effects it'll have on our deficits and debt, but actually it also makes it harder for us if we spend that much money to invest in our public health infrastructure.
And the first issue we began with around both pandemic risks, bioterrorism risks, lab leak risks, those are real risks. And we have to be making investments in biosurveillance, in building up capacity to respond to those things. And it's going to be hard to make those investments if all of our money is flowing into healthcare. So these issues are actually linked together. And the last thing I will say is, look, you know, over the last five years, I spent a lot of time in the public sphere, in government.
I have come to conclude that there is a fringe on the left, ten-fifteen percent, a fringe on the right, sort of ten-fifteen percent, who are super partisan, super loud, who end up dominating the conversation. And then there is a broad middle of 70% of Americans. Some a little to the left, some a little to the right, but all generally pretty reasonable. And that's the group that is not being listened to. And they're not loud.
They don't spend all their time on social media. They don't go around yelling at other people. They're trying to live their lives, but they are the ones that we should be focused on and we should be figuring out. And we should be willing to take the arrows from extremes to make policy suggestions for that broad middle. And that's the broad middle that I have always tried to speak to and I care about.
And if that means that people in the far left and far right hate me, it's okay. I have a dog who loves me. I don't care if anybody else does. My job is to keep saying what I think is right. And then I think if we can all focus on that, I think we can make real progress.
You know, I I could not agree with you more. And whether or not you call it the silent majority or some people call it the exhausted in majority. The real question is why haven't hasn't anybody in a long time been able to build a coalition around that 70%? And I and I I think, you know, again, with the algorithms and the way our system is set up now where we are purposely making each side angry, That's a real issue. And then I unfortunately think that some of the challenges with democracy is that unless there's a crisis, you really don't get the political will to make the tough decisions.
And as much as you and I in the wilderness are yelling and screaming saying we gotta get our priorities in line, I mean, as you pointed out, if you don't have these things under control, you don't get to plan for the future. We're now at a point with, like, interest on the debt and some of these other out of control expenses that it is making it financially difficult to plan for the future. And so I am constantly hoping that we can get people like you to be able to kind of energize that middle. Right? And and and and build a sane policy around practical compromise, but it it's been a long time, and no one seems to be able to energize that base well enough to really make these tough decisions.
Yeah. Well, that's our job. We gotta keep plugging away at it. And if we believe that 70% of Americans are in that bucket, then we've got to get 70% of policy people and experts and political leaders to also decide that that's where they wanna spend their time. And that's why I was excited to come on and spend time chatting with you because I feel like if we all pull together on this, I gotta believe we're gonna be able to make a difference.
Absolutely. Well, doctor John, thank you so, so much for joining us today. It's my pleasure. The top venture capital beyond is produced by CMVG Advisors. If you enjoyed the conversation today and haven't yet subscribed to our show, you can find us on iTunes, Apple Podcasts, and SoundCloud.
Feel free to leave a review while you are there and maybe even a five star rating. Thanks for listening. We'll be back soon with a new episode.